
Martin Kelner – in his weekly Screen Break column has gone in studs up on John Inverdale – particularly regarding the BBC presenter’s fast-and-loose use of the word ‘literally’.
The “Irish players know the eyes of the nation are literally upon them,” he said on Saturday, allegedly. Jamie Redknapp regularly transports footballers to the magnetic north pole on a weekly basis of course as he often suggests they’re, ‘literally, on top of the world’. Top, top punditry, Richard.
Kelner goes on to pick apart the BBC’s coverage of the championships – Austin Healy in the stand, the unintentionally hilarious Sonya on the line, Eddie Butler in the gantry with either Brian Moore or the excellent Philip Matthews.
And then we have RTE. When Ireland beat Romania on penos in 1990, famously the country was snapped back to the Montrose Studio to find Dunphy and Billo in funny hats.
On Saturday, an RTE runner was dispatched to the bowels of Montrose as the full-time whistle went in Cardiff. There, in the corner of a dusty archive stacked neatly between Bibi Baskin and a rotting picture of Gerry Ryan is a worn box marked ‘comedy headgear; use in case of emergency’. It is returned in haste through the corridors to the studio. We, the viewers, return to Donnybrook after the dramatic finale to find, lo and behold, our panel of experts wearing an imaginative melange of millinery, happily gazing back at us – like cows who caught their reflection in a puddle. Absolute gold. (Pic of Mr G Hook from Vic)
Their punditry in general has been pretty run of the mill; Hook draws wild comparisons all day – most things are like Obama, it seems – Popey needles him a bit, offers some sensible opinions and Conor O’Shea fills the John Waters archetype on the Late Late vying for talk time between the Dunph and Eoin Harris. It does what it says on the tin.
My own inclination in general, when I have a choice between the national broadcaster and a British channel in covering any sporting occasion is usually to buy Irish. The difference between the two rugby-wise is really the segments between matches where the BBC treat us to some quality VTs like Keith Wood interviewing Declan Kidney, Woodie close to tears waffling about what we need to do to win and atone for all those past misses, Woodie and O’Driscoll etc. Jonathan Davies often brings a lot of insight to the party too.
Some Irish reader left this remark on the Guardian blog:
I have two words for all of our neighbours who think they are gipped by their public broadcaster when it comes to rubbish rugby commentators: Ryle Nugent.
Actually, that should be three words: Ryle Effing Nugent.
I never thought I would actually miss Fred Cogley, but I did on Saturday night. I would have slept with the hideous old duffer if that would have somehow guaranteed Nugent would be banned from the airwaves forever.
Jesus H Macy. Ryle Nugent is definitely not bad enough to drive you into the arms of Fred Cogley surely? Into the arms of the BBC however? Maybe, some – not I – would say.
But then a man’s relationship with his television sports commentator is like that between and man and a woman. And, God knows, there’s not many Eddie Butlers on the dancefloor of life. Quite literally.